The Struggles Home Sellers Face: Roof Lifespan and the Real Estate Market in South Florida

As any seasoned real estate professional can tell you, selling a home is about more than just staging the interiors and finding the right price point. There are many factors that can complicate a sale, and in areas like South Florida, one of the most significant is the condition and age of the home's roof.

Roof age and its impact on insurance eligibility is a hurdle many sellers encounter. Insurance companies often have stringent guidelines about the remaining life expectancy of a roof before they will issue a policy. This can become a major roadblock in the sales process, as most lenders require proof of insurance before they will close on a mortgage.

Let's dig a bit deeper into this issue, starting with the basics.

Roof Lifespan: Shingle, Tile, and Metal

A roof's lifespan depends heavily on the type of material used, maintenance, and environmental conditions.

1. Asphalt Shingles: These are the most common type of roofing material. Generally, they last between 20 and 25 years. However, in harsh climates like South Florida, where the roofs are subjected to extreme heat, heavy rain, and even hurricanes, their lifespan is reduced to 10-15 years.

2. Tile Roofs: A tile roof is a durable option that can last between 20-25 years years or more with proper maintenance. They're more resistant to the elements than shingle roofs and can better withstand the harsh Florida climate.

3. Metal Roofs: Metal roofs are the most durable, often lasting 50 years or more. They are resistant to extreme weather conditions, making them a good choice for Florida homes. However, they do require special installation and maintenance.

The Seller's Struggle

So, you're a homeowner with an old but well-maintained roof, ready to put your house on the market. You may be faced with a difficult reality when you learn that despite its excellent condition, the age of your roof could be a major stumbling block in the sale.

Why is this the case? Many insurance companies refuse to insure roofs that have less than five years of life expectancy. The determination is usually based on an inspection, and the inspector's report often focuses more on the age than the condition of the roof. Even if your roof has been impeccably maintained, if it's nearing the end of its typical lifespan (10-15 years for shingles, 20-25 for tile and 50+ for metal), it may be deemed uninsurable.

Without insurance, most potential buyers cannot secure a mortgage, leading to a potential deal falling through.

Navigating the Issue

If you're in this situation, what can you do? Here are a few suggestions:

• Have Your Roof Assessed: A qualified roofing professional can provide an accurate estimate of your roof's remaining lifespan.
• Be Proactive: If your roof is nearing the end of its typical lifespan, consider replacing it before listing your home. While this is a significant expense, it could make the selling process smoother and faster.
• Negotiate: If you can't or won't replace the roof, be prepared to negotiate with potential buyers. They may ask for a price reduction or for the roof replacement to be included as part of the home sale agreement.

Understanding the lifespan of your roof and the potential implications on the sale of your home is a crucial part of the selling process. By staying informed and proactive, you can navigate these challenges and ensure a smooth and successful home sale.

But I have insurance now! I have my 4point inspection and it is acceptable. Does that matter?

Yes, it does matter, but it might not necessarily resolve all potential issues when selling a house.

Here's why:

If you currently have insurance and they have evaluated your roof as being acceptable, this indicates that your insurance company is willing to cover your home under their policy. That's certainly a positive point. However, this does not automatically mean that a new insurance company (chosen by the potential buyer) will have the same viewpoint. The new insurer will likely conduct their own inspection and make a decision based on their criteria, which could be different from your current insurer.

Furthermore, even if your current insurance company finds the roof acceptable now, that doesn't necessarily mean they'll continue to do so indefinitely. As the roof ages, your insurer may reevaluate the situation. This could be triggered by a significant event (like a severe storm) or simply by the passage of time.

So, while having current insurance that deems your roof as acceptable is definitely a good thing, it's not a guarantee that the roof won't become an issue when you try to sell the house. The best way to address this potential problem is to maintain good communication with your insurance company, keep your roof in the best possible condition, and consult with a professional roofer to evaluate the condition and estimated remaining lifespan of your roof.

Bottom Line